Wednesday, August 25, 2004
Mr. Esmay opines, though, that high oil prices could result in considerable turmoil in the Middle East, if a higher degree of political stability is not attained. No debate there. However, there has been turmoil in that regoin for a long time. The people there are used to it. Therefore, I am not too worried about it. That is not where the next World War will start.
The next World War will start in the Caspian region:
The Caspian region has 17 to 33 billion barrels of oil in proven reserves. There are credible estimates that the total reserves are likely to be in the 171 to 191 billion range. In addition, there is considerable natural gas. Proven natural gas reserves are around 232 trillion cubic feet. (1 2)
A quick look at the map will show what the problem is. Russia holds only a small minority of the hydrocarbon resources in the area. Russia, Ukraine, and Turkey are stable countries; Georgia is fairly stable; the rest are not. The problem is not getting the hydocarbons out of the ground. The problem is transporting it safely. The majority of the energy reserves would have to go through at least some highly unstable territory, in order to get to world markets.
|Caspian Sea Region Oil Reserves, Production, & Exports (1996) (Production & Export @ thousands barrels/day)|
|Ttl Reserves*||Production||Exports||Major Exporting Cities|
|Iran**||12 BBL||0.0||0.0||Neka / Kharg Island|
|Kazakstan||95-101 BBL||532.1||254.5||Tengiz / Aktyubinsk / Atrau|
|Russia**||5 BBL||52.0||0.0||Novorossisk / Terskoye|
|Turkmenistan||34 BBL||103.9||26.4||Turkmenbashi / Charjou|
There are two safety concerns: the vulnerability of the pipelines and shipping routes, and the vulnerability of the environment. The pipelines would be very difficult to defend. If the hydrocarbon makes it through the pipeline, it then will have to be loaded on a tanker. Anything going through Turkey would have to be transported by ship on the Black Sea and/or the Mediterranian, then the Straits of Gibraltar. If it goes through the Black Sea, it would also have to go through the Bosporus Straits. Any spill east of Gibraltar would be an environmental catastophe. Ships are especially vulnerable in either Straits.
Note that the geography is such that no one nation can be completely independent in the production, transportation, and marketing of their hydrocarbon energy resources. With the exception of Russia's relatively small slice of the pie, all the other reserves would involve at least three countries: the producer, the country with the transportation route, and the customer. How many terrorist acts would it take to start a war in the region?
So far, we have spent a lot of money on the Iraq War:
If we had spent that money on development of fuel cells, biodiesel, solar, and wind power, would the next war even be necessary?
(Note: The Rest of the Story/Corpus Callosum has moved. Visit the new site here.)
E-mail a link that points to this post: